YOU MAY THINK you have an idea of what Sirens, Netflix's new darkly comedic limited series set in the fictional beach resort town of "Port Haven," is all about. The last few years of television have been chock full of shows centered on Rich People Behaving Badly and Getting Themselves Into Trouble.

Showrunner Molly Smith Metzler, director Nicole Kassell, stars Fahy and Alcock stand by the Netflix series’ unexpected finale: “I hope this is a debate people are having.”

The addictive show fully filled a White Lotus shaped hole in our hearts—complete with a shocking twist. Spoilers ahead so turn back now if you haven't watched, but Sirens ends with a recently-fired Simone getting the ultimate revenge on Michaela by essentially stealing her life—taking her place by Peter's side at the Kell's annual gala and shutting the door on her past.