And, of course, Mario, Peach and Bowser, and everything else in this adorable version of the Mushroom Kingdom, are made of paper. But under the surface, Sticker Star is a very different game.

That game was Paper Mario: Sticker Star, and even though it wasn’t held in high regard, a new discovery has been unearthed over a decade later to show the game in a new light.

All the Latest Game Footage and Images from Paper Mario: Sticker Star Have you ever played a video game that you had trouble describing as either "good" or "bad"? Have you ever played something so ...

Sticker Star's eventual followup, Paper Mario: Color Splash for the Wii U, refined some of its more divisive elements, making for an overall stronger game that was better received by fans.

Paper Mario: Sticker Star is often thought to be the worst Paper Mario game. Many elements of it leave us scratching our heads, but World 4 is a pleasant exception in the middle of all that.