James Gunn recently addressed the growing fan speculation surrounding Alan Ritchson as a potential candidate for the DCU ’s Batman. In a new interview, he commented on the casting rumors, shared his personal view of Ritchson, and offered a measured response that sparked further interest in the Reacher star’s connection to the role.

While Henry Cavill may no longer be Superman, is there a world where he plays a different role in the DCU? Here’s what we know.